Talking about what might happen if your marriage ends is unlikely to be top of most couples’ wedding-planning lists.
However, for some couples, a pre-nuptial agreement can provide an opportunity to have an open conversation about their finances and agree how they would like certain assets and financial interests to be treated in the future.
A pre-nuptial agreement is not a guarantee of what will happen if a marriage ends, but in most cases, it would be unusual for the agreement not to be upheld.
Demelza Butler, Family Law Partner at Prettys, answers some of the questions couples commonly ask.
What exactly is a pre-nuptial agreement?
A pre-nuptial agreement, or ‘pre-nup’, is an agreement made by a couple before they marry which sets out their intentions about how their finances should be dealt with if they later divorce.
It can cover a range of financial matters, including assets owned before the marriage, business interests, inherited wealth, property and other investments.
The agreement should be tailored to the couple’s individual circumstances rather than treated as a standard document.
Are pre-nuptial agreements legally binding?
Not automatically.
In England and Wales, the court retains discretion when deciding financial matters following divorce. A pre-nuptial agreement cannot remove that discretion.
However, the Supreme Court has established that significant weight can be given to a pre-nuptial agreement where it was freely entered into by both parties, each had a full appreciation of its implications, and it would not be unfair to hold them to their agreement.
This is why the circumstances in which an agreement is negotiated and signed can be just as important as the wording of the agreement itself.
So, does a pre-nup guarantee that I’ll keep everything I bring into the marriage?
No.
A pre-nup can set out the couple’s intentions, but it cannot guarantee a particular financial outcome years into the future.
Circumstances can change considerably during a marriage. The couple may have children, one person may give up work to care for them, assets may increase or decrease in value, or one person’s financial needs may become very different from those anticipated when the agreement was signed.
These factors can all become relevant if the marriage ends. That is why it is often sensible to review a pre nup agreement at appropriate times to ensure that it still meets your needs.
Do I need a pre-nup if I’m not wealthy?
Quite possibly, having significant wealth is not a prerequisite for considering one. Your financial position before you marry may change significantly during the marriage, assets that you did not consider valuable at the time may grow in value unexpectedly or you may receive gifts that you didn’t expect to receive. An asset doesn’t have to be in your ownership at the time. A pre nup will often deal with gifts or inheritance that you might receive during the course of the marriage.
Equally, you may own a property before getting married, have an interest in a family business, have received an inheritance or expect to receive one in the future.
You may also simply want greater clarity about how you and your partner intend to organise your finances.
The important question is not simply how much money you have, but whether there are financial circumstances that you both want to address before getting married.
Can a pre-nup protect an inheritance?
It can set out the parties’ intentions regarding inherited or family wealth, but it cannot guarantee that an inheritance will always be excluded from consideration on divorce. As above, the court will always retain a discretion to divide the assets as it considers appropriate.
The way an asset is treated can depend on the circumstances, including how it has been used during the marriage and the financial needs of the family.
Protecting inherited or family wealth is often the reason why people want a pre nup.
What about my business?
A business can be one of the more complicated assets to consider as part of a pre-nup.
If one person owns a business before marriage, the agreement can address the couple’s intentions regarding that interest and what should happen if they divorce.
It is important to consider not just the value of the business but also its income, future growth and the potential impact of a divorce on the business itself.
Do we both need our own solicitors?
Independent legal advice for both parties is strongly advisable.
A pre-nup is intended to reflect an agreement reached between two people, so each person should have the opportunity to understand the proposed terms and their potential implications.
Independent advice can also help demonstrate that both parties entered into the agreement freely and with an understanding of what they were agreeing to.
What if my partner asks me to sign one and I don’t want to?
A pre-nup should not be something that one person is pressured into signing.
If one person has concerns about the agreement, those concerns should be discussed and legal advice obtained before anything is signed.
This is one reason why starting the process early is important. It gives both people time to consider the terms properly rather than feeling that they have to agree because the wedding is imminent.
How far in advance of the wedding should we sign it?
There is no single statutory deadline, but it is advisable to sign it at least 28 days prior to the wedding so leaving it until the last minute is best avoided.
The closer an agreement is entered into to the wedding, the greater the potential concern that one party may have felt under pressure to sign.
Starting the process several months before the wedding gives both parties time to obtain independent legal advice, consider the proposed terms and negotiate if necessary.
Do we have to disclose our finances?
Full and frank financial disclosure is an important part of the process.
Each person should have a proper understanding of the other’s financial circumstances when entering into an agreement.
This can include assets, property, investments, business interests, liabilities and other relevant financial information.
A pre-nup should not be based on one person making decisions without having a proper understanding of the financial position being addressed.
What happens if we have children after signing the pre-nup?
This is one of the reasons why a pre-nup should not be viewed as something that fixes every financial issue permanently.
Having children can significantly change a couple’s circumstances. One person may reduce their working hours or stop working altogether, childcare costs may arise and the family’s housing needs may change.
The needs of children can also be highly relevant when financial arrangements are considered following divorce.
For these reasons, it can be sensible to review a pre-nup if there is a significant change in circumstances.
Can we change the agreement after we get married?
Yes.
A couple can review their financial arrangements after marriage and may choose to enter into a post-nuptial agreement.
This can be particularly relevant where circumstances have changed significantly, such as the birth of children, a substantial change in wealth, a business acquisition or another major financial event.
Reviewing an agreement does not mean expecting the marriage to fail. It can simply ensure that the arrangements continue to reflect the couple’s circumstances and intentions.
What if we have already been married for several years?
It is too late for a pre-nup once you are married, but that does not mean it is too late to consider a formal agreement about your financial arrangements.
A post-nuptial agreement can serve a similar purpose and can provide an opportunity for a married couple to record their intentions about their finances.
The same principles around independent advice, financial disclosure and freely entering into the agreement remain important.
Are pre-nups only useful if you divorce?
The main purpose of a pre-nup is to address what should happen if the marriage ends, but the process of creating one can also encourage couples to have conversations about their finances before getting married.
That might include discussing existing assets, debts, family wealth, business interests and how finances will be managed during the marriage.
For some couples, that clarity is valuable in its own right.
What happens if we decide not to have a pre-nup?
There is no legal requirement for a couple to enter into a pre-nuptial agreement.
If you decide not to, the financial consequences of any future divorce will be determined according to the law and the circumstances at that time.
Whether a pre-nup is appropriate is ultimately a personal decision, but taking legal advice can help you understand the potential benefits and limitations before deciding.
So, should we have a pre-nup?
There is no universal answer.
For some couples, a pre-nup provides useful clarity around existing assets, family wealth or business interests. For others, it may not be necessary or appropriate.
What matters is that both people understand what a pre-nup can and cannot achieve and have enough time to consider the decision properly.
If you are considering a pre-nuptial agreement, speaking to a specialist Family Law solicitor early in the process can help you understand your options and ensure that the agreement reflects your individual circumstances.
How can Prettys help?
At Prettys, our Family Law team can advise on the preparation and negotiation of pre-nuptial and post-nuptial agreements.
We take the time to understand your circumstances, explain the legal position clearly and help you consider the practical implications of the agreement.
If you are getting married and considering a pre-nuptial agreement, starting the conversation early can give both you and your partner the time and space to make an informed decision.
If you’re considering a pre-nuptial agreement and would like to understand whether one is right for you, Demelza Butler, Family Law Partner at Prettys, can help. Get in touch with Demelza for friendly, practical advice tailored to your circumstances and the options available to you.