For many logistics providers, there is comfort in the use of standard trading terms which are often based on those of trade bodies such as the RHA, BIFA or UKWA. They are well drafted, have stood the test of time and include allocations of risk and limitations of liability which constitute a strong and reliable platform for insurance. But is it safe to think that reliance on them will provide protection against large or uninsured claims?
The straightforward answer is no. So why not? It’s because there are some commonly occurring contractual scenarios which can cause the protection which they afford to be diluted or even negated entirely. Amongst them are:
The Customer’s Own Contract Terms
If a logistics provider is party to a written contract for the provision of services prepared by the customer, it is likely that the contract will set out performance obligations which the provider has to adhere to and the consequences of its failure to do so. The consequences typically range from contract termination to service credits/rebates through to financial compensation. There are also likely to be provisions about allocation and passing of risk, limitations of liability and the basis on which any losses arising from breach or non-performance of its obligations by the provider would be calculated which are favourable to the customer. These may include:
• Excluding industry standard terms and replacing them with different allocations of risk and higher (or possibly no) limits on amounts recoverable.
• An indemnity basis of recovery which is likely to be more advantageous to the customer.
• Increased insurance requirements.
The Battle of the Forms
It may be the case that a logistics provider has put forward its standard terms in its quote for a piece of work but in its order for that piece of work, the customer has said that the order is on and subject to its standard terms. Which would prevail?
As a general rule, in a battle of standard forms, the last set of terms put forward before the contract is entered into will trump the other set. Customers’ terms may therefore govern the contract with a corresponding increase in the logistics provider’s exposure, often in the areas of responsibility, risk and liability limitations.
Sub-Contracting
If a logistics provider is engaged on a sub-contracted basis, the main contractor by whom they are engaged may contract with them on its own standard terms. Alternatively, it may offer a sub-contract on terms which pull provisions relating to performance, risk and liability down into the sub-contract from its own contract with its customer so that it can have back-to-back protection against any issues arising from the sub-contractor’s performance. Either method of sub-contracting is likely to create an exposure for the sub-contracted logistics provider beyond its own standard terms and related insurance cover.
If a logistics provider is a party to a contract on its customer’s terms, the contract will often require it to put any sub-contractors under an obligation to provide services in a manner consistent with and to have insurance to the levels required by the customer contract. Customer contracts will also often include an indemnity, which may be unlimited, by the logistics provider in favour of the customer under which it indemnifies the customer against any failure by the sub-contractor to provide services to the standard of the customer contract.
What Should Logistics Providers Do?
Standard trading terms remain an essential part of risk management and are often the foundation upon which insurance arrangements are built. However, businesses should not assume that their standard terms will automatically apply to every contract or provide protection against every claim.
Before entering into new customer contracts, accepting purchase orders, or agreeing sub-contract arrangements, logistics providers should carefully review the contractual terms being proposed and consider how they interact with their own trading conditions and insurance cover.
Particular attention should be paid to liability provisions, indemnities, insurance requirements and any clauses which seek to exclude standard industry terms. A contract which appears commercially attractive can significantly increase risk exposure if these provisions are overlooked.
Regular contractual reviews, combined with appropriate legal advice where necessary, can help identify potential issues before they become costly disputes and ensure that contractual liabilities remain aligned with insurance protection.
Standard terms are an important safeguard, but they should be viewed as the starting point rather than the complete solution to contractual risk management.
How Prettys Can Help
If you would like to discuss your existing contractual arrangements or review whether your current terms adequately protect your business against today’s evolving risks in the logistics sector, please get in touch with Ian Waine, who will be pleased to assist.
You can view our Logistics Legal Services to see how Prettys can support your business.
Stay informed with our Logistics mailing list
Want practical legal insights that matter to your logistics business?
Join the Prettys Logistics mailing list to receive:
- Practical legal updates from our specialist team
- Invitations to webinars and industry events
- Articles covering the latest legal and commercial developments affecting the logistics sector
- Expert guidance delivered straight to your inbox
Whether you’re involved in transport, freight, warehousing or the wider supply chain, our updates are designed to help you stay informed and ahead of legal issues that could impact your business.