Delivery Disputes: Who Is Legally Liable When Goods Go Wrong?

When goods are damaged, delayed or fail to arrive altogether, the immediate reaction is often to ask, “Who’s going to pay for this?”

For businesses in the logistics sector, the answer is rarely straightforward. Modern supply chains involve multiple parties – manufacturers, freight forwarders, warehouse operators, hauliers and subcontractors – each with different contractual responsibilities. Just because a claim lands on your desk doesn’t necessarily mean your business is legally liable.

Determining liability requires more than simply identifying where the problem occurred. It means understanding the contractual arrangements, the legal framework governing the movement of the goods and, in some cases, the international conventions that apply.

The Contract Often Decides the Outcome

Many logistics disputes are won or lost before anyone considers what happened to the goods themselves.

The starting point is almost always the contract between the parties. Well-drafted terms and conditions can allocate risk, limit liability and impose strict notification requirements. Equally, poorly incorporated terms may offer little protection at all.

Freight forwarders, for example, often rely on the British International Freight Association (BIFA) Standard Trading Conditions, while many hauliers trade under the Road Haulage Association (RHA) Conditions of Carriage. Both are designed to manage commercial risk, but they are only effective if they have been properly incorporated into the contract.

It is not uncommon for disputes to focus less on how the loss occurred and more on whether those contractual protections actually apply.

Which Legal Rules Apply?

Not every logistics dispute is governed solely by English contract law.

For international road transport, liability is frequently determined by the Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR). The Convention establishes when a carrier will be liable for loss, damage or delay, limits the compensation that may be recoverable and imposes relatively short time limits for bringing claims.

Where goods are transported by sea, a different legal framework may apply, including the Hague-Visby Rules and the Carriage of Goods by Sea Acts 1971 and 1992.

Understanding which legal regime applies is often the first step in assessing whether a claim has merit.

Be Careful About Admitting Liability

When a customer relationship is at stake, there is often pressure to resolve matters quickly.

However, admitting liability before establishing the facts can significantly weaken your legal position. We’ve seen situations where businesses have offered compensation as a commercial gesture, only to discover later that responsibility lay elsewhere in the supply chain.

Before accepting responsibility, consider:

• Who had contractual responsibility for the goods at the relevant time?
• Which terms and conditions govern the agreement?
• Is liability limited by contract or by statute?
• Was another party responsible for the loss or delay?
• What evidence supports the claim?

These questions are far easier to answer before commitments are made than afterwards.

Good Records Win Cases

When disputes reach solicitors, the businesses in the strongest position are usually those with the best documentation.

Delivery notes, photographs, GPS data, booking confirmations, inspection reports and email correspondence can all prove invaluable in establishing what happened and who was responsible.

In practice, disputes are often resolved because the documentary evidence clearly supports one party’s account, rather than because of lengthy legal argument.

The Courts Continue to Uphold Commercial Agreements

The courts have consistently recognised the importance of certainty in commercial contracts. Between businesses of broadly equal bargaining strength, limitation of liability clauses will often be upheld, provided they have been properly incorporated and satisfy the reasonableness requirements of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.

For logistics businesses, that serves as an important reminder that standard terms should not simply be filed away and forgotten. They should be reviewed regularly to ensure they remain fit for purpose and reflect how the business actually operates.

Early Advice Can Save Significant Time and Cost

Many logistics disputes never reach trial. Early legal advice can help identify whether a claim has real prospects of success, preserve key evidence and explore commercial solutions before positions become entrenched.

That is often the difference between resolving a dispute quickly and becoming involved in lengthy, expensive litigation.

How We Can Help

Our Dispute Resolution team advises freight forwarders, hauliers, warehouse operators and other businesses across the logistics sector on contractual disputes, freight claims, cargo damage, debt recovery and supply chain disputes.

Every case turns on its own facts, but understanding your contractual position and the legal framework that applies at an early stage can make a significant difference to protecting your position and achieving the best possible outcome.

If you are facing a logistics dispute, or would like to review whether your existing contracts and terms provide the protection your business needs, please contact Graham Mead, who will be happy to discuss how we can assist.

Find out more about how Prettys supports businesses operating in the logistics sector through our Logistics Legal Services.

Stay informed with our Logistics mailing list

Want practical legal insights that matter to your logistics business?

Join the Prettys Logistics mailing list to receive:

• Practical legal updates from our specialist team
• Invitations to webinars and industry events
• Articles covering the latest legal and commercial developments affecting the logistics sector
• Expert guidance delivered straight to your inbox

Whether you’re involved in transport, freight, warehousing or the wider supply chain, our updates are designed to help you stay informed and ahead of legal issues that could impact your business.

Join our Logistics mailing list today